Kirsten Stoebenau

Yin and Yang: Fertility decline and the rise of women

Tue, 10/30/2012

The ICRW-led Fertility Empowerment Network has just released the latest three installments of its 12-part series of working papers exploring the transformative power of fertility decline around the world. Find out how lower birth rates in China and beyond are positively impacting women’s lives.

The ICRW-led Fertility Empowerment Network has just released the latest three installments of its 12-part series of working papers exploring the transformative power of fertility decline around the world. Find out how lower birth rates in China and beyond are positively impacting women’s lives.

A network of academic and applied researchers led by the International Center for Research on Women (ICRW) has released three new working papers in a 12-study series that explores how dramatic fertility declines over the last 40 years have affected women’s lives and gender relations in low- and middle-income countries.

The group, called the Fertility & Empowerment Network, is testing the following important questions: Does demographic change – specifically, having smaller families – alter women’s well-being and the gender norms in a society? Are women in developing countries becoming more empowered – that is, are they able to exercise control over strategic life choices – as they gain greater access to birth control and have fewer children – and if so, how? Have fertility declines helped create more equitable relationships and opportunities for women?

The latest papers provide a range of new evidence regarding the impact of fertility decline on women’s well-being and empowerment. Two of them, A Macro-level Exploration of the Links between Fertility Decline and Gender Equality, Lee-Rife, et al, and Fertility Decline, Women’s Well-being, and Gender Gaps in Well-being in Poor Countries, Yount, et al, look at the effects of fertility decline across a wide range of countries. The third, Fertility Decline and Women’s Empowerment in China, Wu, et al, focuses on China, a country that has experienced one of the most remarkable fertility declines in the last few decades.

Wu et al found that in China women with fewer children do less housework and tend to be more satisfied with their status within family as compared to women with more children, and that these associations have grown more significant over time. In addition, they found that girls who grow up in households with fewer siblings (smaller families) tend to stay in school longer and continue on to improved chances of occupational attainment as compared to girls with more brothers and sisters.

Yount et al’s country-level study indicates that girls – not only women – benefit from fertility decline. The trend is linked to improved school attendance, nutritional status and access to vaccinations against disease. However, the relative gains to girls are not as great as they are for boys. But interestingly, the researchers found that the relative gains for girls’ wellbeing outstrip those of boys when a woman experiences her first birth at a relatively higher age.

Lee-Rife et al also use country-level data to compare the timing of fertility decline with relative gains to women’s labor force participation and educational attainment. Their findings demonstrate that fertility decline often precedes narrowing gendered gaps in these outcomes.

Additional working papers will be released soon, which will add to the complex understanding of if and how women’s lives have benefitted from fertility change in other places around the world, including Iran, Southern India, South Africa and the Philippines.

The first three papers were posted earlier this year on the eve of the May 3-5 annual Population Association of America conference in San Francisco. They can be downloaded here:

Kirsten Stoebenau is gender and population specialist who focuses on women’s reproductive and sexual health.

Network Launches Innovative Working Paper Series on Fertility Declines

ICRW experts and others to present findings at Population Association of America conference
Tue, 05/01/2012

The Fertility & Empowerment Network releases first three papers in a series that explores how having smaller families has affected women’s lives in developing countries.

A network of academic and applied researchers led by the International Center for Research on Women (ICRW) this week will launch a series of working papers that explores how dramatic fertility declines over the last 40 years have affected women’s lives and gender relations in low- and middle-income countries. 

The group, called the Fertility & Empowerment Network, is testing the following important questions: Does demographic change – specifically, having smaller families – alter women’s well-being and the gender norms in a society? Are women in developing countries becoming more empowered – that is, are they able to exercise control over strategic life choices – as they gain greater access to birth control and have fewer children – and if so, how? Have fertility declines helped create more equitable relationships and opportunities for women? 

To be sure, it is difficult to prove that access to contraception and reductions in family size contribute directly to empowering women and transforming gender relations. However, the network’s findings provide indications that having fewer children may indeed be shifting roles and norms within a household. For example, researcher Keera Allendorf shows in her case study of a village in Northern India that — in the context of smaller families — daughters are increasingly being tapped to support aging parents. It’s a role that once was expected only of sons, and a reason that families traditionally invested more in sons than in daughters.

“Women’s empowerment and gender equality are widely recognized as key to achieving our broader development goals to reduce poverty and improve health,” said Kirsten Stoebenau, ICRW’s gender and population specialist. “The network’s goal is to provide insights on how programs and policies can maximize the positive outcomes of the connection between declining fertility and women’s empowerment.” 

Network members, including ICRW experts, will debut six of the papers in the 13-study series during the annual Population Association of America conference May 3 – 5 in San Francisco. The first three are now available for download: 

Related: Commentary: Does Access to Contraception Empower Women?

Commentary: Does Access to Contraception Empower Women?

Link Between Fertility Declines and Women’s Empowerment Could be Transformative
Mon, 07/11/2011

Today, on World Population Day, ICRW considers whether a woman’s ability to control when and how many children she has results in her becoming more empowered.

Does Access to Contraception Empower Women?Empowering women – that is, creating conditions that build their confidence, self-reliance and ability to make strategic life choices – is increasingly seen as a key to achieving broad international development goals. Indeed, research and policy in the field have coalesced around the importance of women’s empowerment to fostering economic prosperity, healthy communities and more equitable relationships. And studies show that when women are able to take control of their lives, others benefit – their children are educated and healthier, their families more financially stable.

Such positive outcomes of empowering women can come from a variety of opportunities, such as completing secondary school and earning money. But a crucial contribution to women’s empowerment that’s missing from the global dialogue on the issue is the role that increased access to contraception and reductions in family size in low- and middle-income countries play toward empowering women and transforming gender inequalities. At ICRW, we believe this is one of the most important considerations of this century -- the world is finally poised to not only address the needs of women as 50 percent of humanity, but also to realize their contributions to a more productive, egalitarian and sustainable planet.

Over the past several decades, debates about the role of family planning programs have evolved. From the 1960s to the 1980s, the main emphasis was on the role of family planning in lowering fertility levels and stabilizing population growth, as a route to sustainable development. In the 1990s, the integration of women’s reproductive health and rights into the delivery of family planning services gained importance. As we progress in the new millennium, both these issues remain relevant, but family planning programs have the potential to play an even larger role in creating social change.

Today, most women around the globe want to have fewer children than they did 40 years ago. This is evidenced by the dramatic decline in the average family size in many countries worldwide – often a result of women’s voluntary use of contraception. For example, in 1960, the average Egyptian woman had 6.6 children, while in 2008, she had only three. That same year, 60 percent of women used contraception, compared to 25 percent in 1970. Similarly in Colombia, the average woman had 6.7 children in 1960, whereas in 2009, she had only 2.4. And while in 2005, 78 percent of Colombian women used contraception, only 21 percent did in 1970, according to UN Women’s Indicators and Statistics Database.

These changes may have profound consequences for women’s lives and position in society. A woman who can choose from easily accessible, widely available contraceptive methods to control when and how many children she has could be better poised to take on roles outside of the domestic sphere. Having such control may also lead to less stringent gendered roles and norms within households. Access to contraception may also contribute to the increasing number of women worldwide who are becoming educated and joining the labor force or becoming civic and political leaders.

But we don’t yet have the evidence to prove this, and that gap in knowledge was the impetus for the newly-formed Fertility & Empowerment Network, a group of academic and applied researchers housed at ICRW. Through theoretical and empirical research, the network is charged with investigating the point we raised earlier: Does access to family planning and giving birth to fewer children empower the world’s women and equalize their relationships with men? The network is encouraging other researchers and advocates of family planning, women’s empowerment and poverty reduction to dig into this question, too.

Our initial analysis suggests that as fertility declines and contraceptive use increases, daughters become as valued as sons in traditionally patriarchal families, parents invest more in their daughters’ education and the gap between spouses’ ages and education narrows, which implies more equity in marital partnerships. If our early analyses are confirmed, we believe it will mean that improving access to voluntary, high quality family planning care can further contribute to a world where women are as educated, as financially stable and as valued as men. 

Kirsten Stoebenau is a gender and population specialist, and Anju Malhotra is vice president of research, innovation and impact at ICRW.

Syndicate content